Sands REPM

3650 McKinley AVE photos

A picture-perfect arrival. Towering palms frame the stately Colonial facade, creating a timeless entrance that feels as welcoming today as it did in 1925.
Located just moments from the Caloosahatchee River and outside the flood zone, this property offers both historic charm and peace of mind.
Perfectly positioned beside the historic Fort Myers Country Club, this rare Seminole Park residence enjoys one of the most recognizable locations in Fort Myers.
Enjoy a front-row seat to one of Florida's most historic golf courses, designed by legendary architect Donald Ross in 1917.
Classic architecture and mature landscaping combine to deliver exceptional curb appeal along iconic McGregor Boulevard.
Historic charm extends outdoors with inviting spaces that encourage year-round Florida living.
Aerial views showcase the home's impressive setting on its own historic block, surrounded by mature trees, charming architecture, and the character that defines Old Fort Myers.
Aerial views showcase the home's impressive setting on its own historic block, surrounded by mature trees, charming architecture, and the character that defines Old Fort Myers.
Designed for entertaining, the outdoor living area offers ample space for dining, grilling, and gathering with friends and family.
Designed for entertaining, the outdoor living area offers ample space for dining, grilling, and gathering with friends and family.
From the moment you step onto the property, the home's historic character and meticulous preservation are immediately apparent.
Few homes offer a dedicated library that so perfectly captures the spirit of a historic Colonial residence.
The heart of the home, this elegant living room features a working wood-burning fireplace, original hardwood flooring, and the timeless craftsmanship that defines this 1925 Colonial.
Gather around the warmth of the original wood-burning fireplace while enjoying beautifully preserved hardwood floors that have welcomed generations of family and friends.
Rich in character and authenticity, this stunning space showcases original wood floors, historic architectural details, and a fully functional fireplace rarely found in homes today.
High ceilings, natural light, original hardwood flooring, and a working wood-burning fireplace create an atmosphere that feels both grand and inviting.
Every detail reflects the home's remarkable preservation, from the gleaming original floors underfoot to the crackling fireplace that remains a centerpiece nearly a century later.
Offering a more casual and comfortable setting, the family room provides a wonderful balance to the home's formal living spaces.
A flexible living area that easily accommodates everything from movie nights to holiday gatherings while preserving the home's historic charm.
Spacious yet cozy, this room was designed for making memories with family and friends.
3650 McKinley AVE photo 21
Every cabinet, trim detail, and architectural element reflects a level of craftsmanship rarely replicated today.
The kitchen serves as a beautiful example of how historic character and modern functionality can coexist.
Rich in historic character, the formal dining room is highlighted by a rare original oscillating fan—a fascinating piece of 1925 ingenuity that still draws admiration today.
The dining room beautifully blends form and function, featuring original hardwood flooring, timeless craftsmanship, and a vintage oscillating fan that serves as both a conversation piece and a reminder of the home's heritage.
Designed for memorable gatherings, this gracious dining space showcases the attention to detail and historic authenticity found throughout the residence.
Classic charm meets practicality in this well-appointed downstairs bathroom, offering easy access from the home's main living spaces.
The beautifully preserved original staircase serves as a stunning centerpiece, showcasing the craftsmanship and attention to detail that defined homes built in the 1920s.
This cozy upstairs landing serves as a charming transition between the bedrooms and baths, complete with two convenient storage closets.
The charming second-floor landing offers easy access to the bedrooms while providing valuable storage through two well-positioned closets.
Spacious and filled with natural light, the primary suite captures the elegance and craftsmanship of a bygone era.
A versatile gathering space ideal for relaxing, entertaining, or creating a cozy media room.
Character-rich details and abundant natural light create a comfortable space for family or guests.
A true showpiece, the original clawfoot tub serves as a stunning reminder of the home's 1925 heritage.
Thoughtfully maintained details create an authentic experience rarely found in today's homes.
Flexible space ideal for guests, hobbies, or a home office while maintaining the home's historic integrity.
This inviting outdoor space extends the home's living area, providing the perfect backdrop for entertaining, dining, or relaxing under the Florida sky.
Designed for entertaining, the outdoor living area offers ample space for dining, grilling, and gathering with friends and family.
Once home to a Model T automobile, this fascinating space has been thoughtfully repurposed into a spacious laundry and utility room while preserving a unique piece of the property's history.
Historic charm meets everyday functionality in the former carriage garage, now serving as an oversized laundry room with abundant storage and workspace.
A unique detached structure currently serves as a private sauna retreat and offers endless possibilities for future use.
A unique detached structure currently serves as a private sauna retreat and offers endless possibilities for future use.
Thoughtfully positioned on its oversized corner homesite, the residence enjoys natural light throughout the day and the beauty of both sunrise and sunset views.
Few properties offer the ability to enjoy the best of both worlds—peaceful morning sunrises and breathtaking evening sunsets that define the Southwest Florida lifestyle.
Wake to the soft glow of sunrise and unwind beneath colorful sunset skies, a daily reminder of why Fort Myers remains one of Florida's most cherished places to call home.
Start your mornings with vibrant sunrises and end your evenings with glowing sunsets, all from one of Fort Myers' most iconic historic neighborhoods.
Positioned to capture both spectacular sunsets and beautiful Southwest Florida sunrises, this historic property offers the rare opportunity to enjoy the changing colors of the sky from dawn until dusk.
First Floor
Second Floor
Detached Garage/Sauna
1 / 50

3650 McKinley AVE, FORT MYERS

Single Family Residence

Active

$699,000

▼ $100,000 (13%)

3

Beds

2

Baths

1,608

Sqft

Est. $4,220/mo · Get pre-qualified

Home Type: Single Family ResidenceYear Built: 1925Sqft: 1,608Price/Sqft: $435Lot Size: 0.351 acres

They don’t build homes like this anymore. Located in historic Seminole Park along the iconic McGregor Boulevard corridor, 3650 McKinley Avenue is a rare opportunity to own a nearly century-old home that has been thoughtfully updated for modern living. Celebrating its centennial in 2025, this property spans an entire block and blends preserved 1925 character with meaningful upgrades. Original details remain throughout, including wood flooring, single-hung sash windows, and architectural elements that reflect the home’s history. The kitchen features preserved 1925 upper cabinetry paired with custom lower cabinets and KitchenAid appliances. Bathrooms include a replica clawfoot tub, pedestal sinks, and restored subway and penny tile. A standout feature is the fully converted Model-T garage, now a functional steam room and laundry space. Outdoor living is expansive, with mature landscaping, a large grilling area, a private irrigation well, and a setting that captures both sunrise and sunset. Major updates include a metal roof (2018), updated HVAC and ductwork (2013–2014), and PVC plumbing (2017), offering added confidence for today’s buyer. The flexible floor plan includes three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a library, a den, a formal living room, and a family room. Conveniently located minutes from the Edison and Ford Winter Estates, downtown River District, golf, dining, and entertainment. A unique historic property offering character, space, and location — ready for its next chapter.

528 days on market · Listing updated July 28, 2026

Location

Facts & Features

Interior Features:
Den - Study, Home Office
Appliances:
Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator/Icemaker, Self Cleaning Oven, Washer
Flooring:
Tile, Wood
Primary Bathroom:
Tub Only
Kitchen:
Pantry
Dining Room:
Formal
Heating:
Central Electric, Fireplace(s)
Cooling:
Central Electric
Utilities:
Cable Available
Sewer:
Assessment Paid
Water Source:
Assessment Paid
Security:
Smoke Detector(s)
Exterior Features:
Grill - Other, Outdoor Grill, Room for Pool, Sprinkler Auto
Construction:
Wood Frame, Stucco
Architectural Style:
See Remarks
Roof:
Metal
Patio / Porch:
Patio
View:
Golf Course
Waterfront:
None
Direction Faces:
Southwest
Lot Features:
Oversize
Irrigation:
Well
Road Surface:
Paved
Road Frontage:
Public Road
Other Structures:
Extra Building
Parking:
Circular Driveway
Windows:
Single Hung, Shutters, Decorative Shutters
Doors:
French Doors
Community Features:
Golf Public, Park, Golf, Hobby Room, Sauna, Sidewalks, Golf Course
Subdivision:
SEMINOLE PARK
Elementary School:
SCHOOL CHOICE
Middle School:
SCHOOL CHOICE
High School:
SCHOOL CHOICE
Zoning:
RS-6
Annual Taxes:
$1,921
Pets Allowed:
No Approval Needed
Furnished:
Turnkey
Possession:
Close Of Escrow
Listing Terms:
Buyer Finance/Cash, FHA
Disclosures:
Seller Disclosure Available

Price History

DateEventPrice
Jul 28, 2026Price change$699,000
Mar 21, 2025Original list price$799,000

Reflects listing data on file, not a complete transaction history.

Listed by Melissa Smith, Royal Shell Real Estate, Inc.

$699,000

3650 McKinley AVE, FORT MYERS

Contact Agent

Request a Tour

Mortgage Calculator

$4,220

est. monthly payment

Estimate only — actual payment depends on your lender, credit profile, and final loan terms.

The data relating to real estate for sale displayed on this Website comes in part from the Multiple Listing Service of the Bonita Springs-Estero Association of REALTORS®, Inc., under License No. BK3468074. Properties displayed on this Website include properties listed with brokerage firms other than Sands Real Estate & Property Management. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the brokerage firm with which the seller has listed the property. The properties displayed may not be all the properties listed with brokerage firms participating in the Bonita Springs-Estero Association of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service, or contained in the database compilation of the Bonita Springs-Estero Association of REALTORS® Multiple Listing Service.